Blu-ray or 4K UHD?

Many 4K packs hold two discs: the 4K UHD Blu-ray and an ordinary Blu-ray. They look alike, but they are different formats. The 4K disc carries four times the pixels and can carry HDR and a wider range of colour. Here is what that changes, what you need at home to see it, and which disc to start with.

The short answer

A Blu-ray is Full HD (1080p). A 4K UHD Blu-ray holds a 4K picture, with four times as many pixels.

Blu-ray4K UHD Blu-ray
ResolutionFull HD (1080p)4K, four times Full HD
Disc capacity25 or 50 GB66 or 100 GB
Plays onBlu-ray and 4K players4K players only

More than resolution

HDR. High dynamic range widens the gap between the darkest and the brightest parts of the picture. That is not the same as making the whole picture brighter. Most 4K discs carry HDR10, the basic HDR format; some add Dolby Vision or HDR10+, which adjust the picture scene by scene. On a TV without Dolby Vision, such a disc can still play in HDR: Sony's support page for its UBP-X700 player shows Dolby Vision content going out as ordinary HDR10 to a 4K HDR TV without Dolby Vision. The formats one by one: 4K disc formats explained.

Colour. A 4K disc can show over 75 % of the visible colour spectrum.

Room. A 4K disc holds 66 or 100 GB, against 25 or 50 GB on a Blu-ray.

A Blu-ray on a 4K TV. The TV scales the picture up to fill its screen, but, as What Hi-Fi puts it, “you can't add what wasn't there to begin with.”

Sound

A 4K disc can carry up to 7.1 channels of uncompressed surround sound, and sound from above in Dolby Atmos or DTS:X, which an ordinary Blu-ray can carry too. The two discs of one pack can also have different soundtracks. On the UK pack of Blade Runner 2049, the back cover lists the English track of the 4K disc as Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1) and that of the Blu-ray as DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. Both are lossless formats; Atmos adds sound from above. More in sound on a 4K disc.

What you need to see 4K HDR

  • A 4K TV with HDR.
  • A 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray player. A standard Blu-ray player cannot play a 4K disc, while a 4K player plays your Blu-rays too. A PS5 with a disc drive plays 4K discs; the PS5 Digital Edition (CFI-1000) takes no discs. An Xbox Series X with a disc drive plays 4K discs, but without Dolby Vision; the all-digital Series X and the Series S take no discs.
  • A Premium High Speed HDMI cable. Certified ones are tested for 4K at 60 Hz, for equipment with HDR.
  • HDCP 2.2 copy protection along the way. Panasonic's manual for its DP-UB820 player says 4K HDR needs a connected device with HDCP 2.2 and 4K HDR support; without HDCP 2.2, that player converts the HDR picture and sends it in 2K, a lower resolution.
  • A soundbar or receiver in the picture path must pass it on, Dolby Vision included.

Which players and TVs do what: what plays 4K discs.

The Blu-ray in the box

Many 4K packs, plenty of ours among them, add the same movie on Blu-ray. It plays on an ordinary Blu-ray player, in Full HD. Its sound and languages can differ from the 4K disc's, so our product pages list each disc's languages separately.

Where to start: Blade Runner 2049

Reviewers agree on this one. What Hi-Fi praised its clarity, rich colours and “terrific black performance”; High-Def Disc News found it “downright visually amazing”. Its cinematographer, Roger Deakins, shot it on ARRI Alexa XT Studio cameras at 3.4K: almost the 4K of a 4K disc, and far more than the Full HD of a Blu-ray. Deakins sat in on the whole final colour grading with colourist Mitch Paulson, who also prepared all the home versions. One honest note: What Hi-Fi found the HDR subtly implemented; the praise is for the detail, colour and black.

Blade Runner 2049: 4K UHD Blu-ray vs. Blu-ray
Blade Runner 2049, the 4K disc and the Blu-ray compared (My moonization, YouTube). HDR shows only when the disc plays on an HDR TV.

The blogger Archimago compared frames of this movie from both discs, crop by crop. He found a “quite obvious resolution improvement” in close-ups and concluded: “Clearly there is a jump in resolution.”

Blade Runner 2049 on 4K UHD (UK pack with the Blu-ray)

Questions

Will a 4K disc play in my Blu-ray player?

No. A 4K UHD Blu-ray needs a 4K player. A 4K player, on the other hand, plays your Blu-rays too.

Do I need a TV with HDR?

To see everything the disc holds, yes: a 4K TV with HDR. For a TV without HDR, a 4K player can convert the picture to SDR, the ordinary picture without HDR.

Does a Dolby Vision disc play on a TV without Dolby Vision?

It can: Sony's support page for its UBP-X700 player shows Dolby Vision content going out as ordinary HDR10 to a 4K HDR TV without Dolby Vision.

Which HDMI cable do I need?

A certified Premium High Speed HDMI cable, which is certified for 4K at 60 Hz.

Does the Xbox Series X play Dolby Vision from a disc?

No. An Xbox Series X with a disc drive plays 4K discs, but without Dolby Vision. The all-digital Series X and the Series S take no discs.

Is the Blu-ray in the pack the same as the 4K Ultra HD disc?

No. Both hold the same movie, but the Blu-ray in Full HD (1080p) and the 4K Ultra HD disc in 4K. Their sound and languages can differ too. On the UK pack of Blade Runner 2049, the 4K Ultra HD disc has Dolby Atmos and the Blu-ray DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1.

Sources

More sources (23)

See 4K steelbooksAll 4K movies